ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
controversial opinion but by the end of the 3rd jedi game cal should be either evil or dead i HIGHLY disagree, highly, highly highly cannot disagree enough with this one
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
don't like that
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
i think he will stray into the dark and it might be a little bit of a battle BUT i feel like that would be cheap when his story is so like - its about hope. and surviving and not giving up, but its about hope and i feel like that would just. suck. honestly.
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
whats tired and done is taking a character who's dealt with trauma and pain and suffered a lot, giving them a tiny bit of happiness and then killing them off
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
yes
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
i think we're forgetting that star wars is about hope
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
and things like. it made sense narratively for the rogue one team to die but i dont think that cal has to die to fit into things!!!!
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
esp with things like tanalorr in the mix, when he and merrin can go fuck off into the unknown regions looking for ancient civilizations and shit
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
which is my guess for the end honestly
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
his journey started with unlocking the secrets of the zeffo so i think they will come into play at the end
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
I would LOVE if the zeffo came back into the mix
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
it would be narratively so satisfying to go full circle like that!
StupidSexyV⚠der
I do think he needs to have face the Dark hard and rise
weggy board
NO
weggy board
I want him to struggle with the dark bc that's clearly where he's going
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
he's deffo going to have to deal with the dark side more, but I think it would be more satisfying for him to rise above it
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
like how cere did
weggy board
but I think putting tanalorr way the fuck out where no one can get to it means he's gonna end up there with merrin
StupidSexyV⚠der
like not just is Star Wars about hope, about how no one is ever too far gone, it's about how the tinyest spark Light will ignite the and grow given the smallest bit of care and will destroy the Darkness
weggy board
they haven't crafted his story as a tragedy thus far imo
weggy board
like star wars is also predictable as fuck a lot of the time
weggy board
ben solo, let's face it, we all kinda knew what was coming
StupidSexyV⚠der
yeah he did
weggy board
esp because I read recently that early on when adam driver was told the character arc, we were never supposed to get the full ben solo flip back to the light
weggy board
he was gonna double down on his stupid shit and die
weggy board
we have rian johnson, sheer chemistry, and loud fans to thank for what we got
skipthedemon
people really wanted Ezra to be Darkside when he returned in canon, too, and I'm like....why
weggy board
so yeah I don't think they've crafted cal's arc as "the hero fights valiantly but goes dark or dies"
skipthedemon
dead I could have lived with, actually
weggy board
also we don't have palpatine pulling Cal's strings
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
yeah like cal's character isn't "dark"
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
he struggles, of course, but he's inherently Good
weggy board
with Anakin and Kylo their real tragedy is they could have gone either way but Palpatine was there to give them the shove over the edge
weggy board
Cal has his own trauma and attachments
weggy board
but he's also not isolated and guided by evil
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
he's not isolated and that is SO important
weggy board
and we've already had Cal's contrasts
weggy board
Trilla, Dagan, Bode
weggy board
if the message here is everyone eventually falls, what the fuck
skipthedemon
agreed
weggy board
so yeah I don't think Cal's gonna go dark
weggy board
I'm 50/50 on him dying
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
I could see them killing him off way before him going dark for real for real
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
I would honestly rather him die than turn darkside and evil because it would feel like a cop out.
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
NOT THAT I WANT THAT
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ : that’s where I’m at
weggy board
I could be okay with his death if it's narratively satisfying and not a case of oh he goes dark and then must die to redeem himself
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
please let cal live with his wife and stolen child and wacky alien uncle
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
Yep. No redemption via death Im over that shit
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
But I’d prefer their weird little family being together and safe somewhere yes.
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
like even if somehow tanalorr gets compromised, let them escape to the unknown regions where the empire doesn't give a shit
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
(I feel weird about tanalorr, like if it's going to be a safe haven that no one else can get to, then why is it introduced halfway through)
weggy board
I think they'll be able to hide some people away there
weggy board
and maybe they'll use it in Rey's trilogy
ᴠᴇʀꜱᴏ
oh that would be interesting as a connection
weggy board
oh there's a whole fresh generation of people who had former jedi parents
weggy board
but they've only just discovered how to get to this planet
StupidSexyV⚠der
"with Anakin and Kylo their real tragedy is they could have gone either way but Palpatine was there to give them the shove over the edge" and EVEN WITH THAT, love brought them back to the Light
StupidSexyV⚠der
that is star wars
weggy board
I think... Cal has a family now, and he doesn't have to be "the" Jedi; we have narratives of the lone Jedi hero. So his story could end with him living out his days on Tanalorr.
weggy board
and to give it weight it could feel like a big sacrifice, like
weggy board
you get to have your family here but you never get to see the rest of the galaxy again, or he's injured in some way that makes it impossible to be the hero but not to train kids
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
honestly like for cal, that would be a great ending - for him it would probably feel like a sacrificce, having to step down and stop fighting -- or not, maybe by that point he will be at peace with himself enough to settle down
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
either way him and merrin being alive and happy together with their strange little family unit is all i want
weggy board
he's been through so much!!!!
weggy board
anyway I pine for soft merrical things now hdu
weggy board
trying to write two more trilla tags like but... soft...
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
lmaooo
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
i want to touch folkmore stuff but i will try and toss one of our fluffy things back at you
weggy board
ty ty
weggy board
Trilla's gonna reply to Vader and Hans tonight if it kills me
StupidSexyV⚠der
have your family, be safe, but know the empire is continuing vs go down fighting the empire is a sacrifice
kiwi burgers
well they acknowledge it's controversial at least
ʏօʊʀ ɨɖօʟ
they did! i didnt feel like having this discussion on tumblr dot com with strangers tho lmao
載入新的回覆