JingleBells
JingleBells
cryogenics is the Christmas story with 11 that is basically Charles Dickens A Christmas Story
JingleBells
and well- Cybermen
JingleBells
Im also hoping we're all ooc laughing at the human brain bit
JingleBells
you seem to know this for a fact dear sir
Yon Fellow
I mean I feel like you describe any scenario and there's probably a Who episode that's at least tangentially relevant.
JingleBells
true
JingleBells
there is a quite a lot but also not everything
JingleBells
but then if you count comics and the non BBC books then there might be everything
JingleBells
thats the grey area where we fight and debate what IS canon ^
JingleBells
Im just - hearing how firm Ten said; Putting a human brain in a robot always ends badly.
JingleBells
and laughing
JingleBells
even if I shoudlnt
Yon Fellow
Buddy, I am a pre-Disney Star Wars fan, I know a little something something about canon debates
JingleBells
yes, yes you do
JingleBells
but some of the comics and books are very problematic because theres a lot of main stream canon that is counterdicted
JingleBells
like I believe - if you go by some books (I forgot which ones)
JingleBells
the Time War didn't happen
Yon Fellow
I buy it
JingleBells
because that was written before the Reboot ^
JingleBells
BUT some of those books that were written in the 'dead years' or even when the show was on in the 70s and 80s like Human Nature / Family of Blood IS from a book
JingleBells
it was just adapted
JingleBells
but yeah if you go by all canon with the books and comics; theres a timeline the Time War didnt happen
Yon Fellow
At least you have the built-in excuse of Wibbly Wobbly
JingleBells
and of course the Peter Crushing movies that arent canon even if they're TV
Yon Fellow
Peter Cushing, Rowan Atkinson, that one cartoon one
JingleBells
yup!
Yon Fellow
Okay the Rowan Atkinson one was always just a comedy sketch but
JingleBells
the cartoon one was a revival attempt
JingleBells
Wibbly wobbly doesnt work when it counter intuitive main stuff
JingleBells
like 12 and Clara not having a toxic relationship in the comics
JingleBells
even if thats Moffats fault for not being to write just friendship
Yon Fellow
Listen, I'm a man who just ignores the fuck out of the Clone Wars cartoon that everybody else adores, so I feel this as well
JingleBells
but yeah Peter Crushing and blanking on the animated one arent considered canon
JingleBells
<3
JingleBells
and then theres the TimeLess Child plot with 13
JingleBells
so how they wrap 13 up and do the 60th; will probably be saying a lot of things
JingleBells
if RTD goes AU with the 60th; he might imply everything is canon
JingleBells
which is why I REALLY think RTD is gonna be doing MoM of sorts
JingleBells
without the Wanda stuff ^
JingleBells
but basically say that all these AUs exist in the Who-verse
JingleBells
so Peter Crushing would be canon in some other universe in Who
JingleBells
and so forth
JingleBells
and you could have a lot of spin off shows with that ^
JingleBells
the Time War didnt happen in some other universe in Who is canon
JingleBells
so we'll see what happens with 13s last episode in October and the 60th
JingleBells
which is slated for 2023 sometime
JingleBells
so I might have to be adding a page to 10s journal of confirmed AU 10s
JingleBells
the problem is just - the writers grew up with Who and read the books and comics and take bits and pieces ALSO ironically The Time War was mentioned briefly in a book before the Reboot
JingleBells
which where the idea came from
JingleBells
that 90 to 2005 downtown of books and comics didnt help this fandom
JingleBells
well it did because that was the only way Who was still alive
JingleBells
otherwise it would have faded into nothing
JingleBells
but yeah; Star Wars, MCU too much STUFF because old canon
JingleBells
but yeah too many chefs in the kitchen basically
JingleBells
shalka Doctor
JingleBells
thats the cartoon
JingleBells
this shows how my brain still isnt completely awake at 3pm
JingleBells
but yeah shalka Doctor isnt canon either
Yon Fellow
SHALKA
Yon Fellow
Right
JingleBells
and the Brain of Morbuis Doctors arent canon either
JingleBells
Even if Chinball is trying to make that canon
JingleBells
but interviews with those who worked on Mobius Doctors have said that was just a 4th wall thing
JingleBells
Chinball do your homework >:<
JingleBells
Yon Fellow Im sounding like how you with Star Wars, arent I?
Yon Fellow
PFFFF.
Yon Fellow
It's totally fin.
Yon Fellow
*Fine
Yon Fellow
:-P
JingleBells
<3
Yon Fellow
But yes, I have a reputation as an unpopular-opinion saltlord
JingleBells
What I do count as canon - besides the TV of course
JingleBells
are the official BBC books and Big Finish
JingleBells
and the Time Lord victorious multi-media thing because that was a huge BBC group project
JingleBells
books, comics, live escape room, online animations and audios ^
JingleBells
that is also where the link of the alien singing came from, the escape room for Who
JingleBells
in our Ten and Obi-Wan thread
JingleBells
Time Fracture is part of the Time Lord Victorious timeline and you can only explore it in London ;3;
載入新的回覆