Cute Quinn
So we like taking tired anime tropes and coming up with twists on them that would actually be fresh and interesting
Cute Quinn
Give me a variation on this trope that doesn't make me want to leave the room:
Cute Quinn
The clumsy bumbling maid
Echo
Maid is secretly a master of drunken fist martial arts, was actually hired as a way to have a bodyguard around under plausible deniability.
Cute Quinn
see the trouble with that kind of angle, which is also my first instinct
Echo
Said deniability would be a little more plausible if she wasn't visibly drunk right now, but hey.
Cute Quinn
is that "cute maid who's secretly a deadly assassin" is ALSO a tired trope
TWO OF THEM
shannon from umineko
Echo
Alternately: maid fucking hates her job, the "clumsy" incidents are actually just her finding a safe excuse to fuck up her employer's possessions/pour soup on his lap/whatever.
Echo
Malicious compliance that she's getting away with because she plays it off all cutesy.
Cute Quinn
I do think there's a certain amount of legs in the idea that the maid is clumsy because she absolutely isn't trying her best
Echo
She doesn't want to be here, fuck this job.
pixie lovemail
Clumsiness is because she's secretly a robot from an advanced civilization without any access to repair facilities. Comedy is all about her hiding the fact that she's a robot and desperately jerry-rigging solutions to her various breakdowns and malfunctions.
Cute Quinn
that feels like it's dangerously close to being mahoromatic
pixie lovemail
Mahoromatic?
Cute Quinn
Cute Quinn
old gainax show about a wacky android maid
AzureChrysanthemum
hahaha I read that and was like
AzureChrysanthemum
"I just remembered Mahoromatic exists and I don't like that"
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
:|a i think there's legs to the idea of the maid is bumbling and clumsy because she kind of hates her job
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
or at least her employer
pixie lovemail
yeah i think echo has the best idea here
skerple
that one slow soothing anime we pulled on the blessed crunchyroulette, the one about the nearsighted maid
Cute Quinn
it's a zany ecchi show where every episode ends with how many days are left until mahoromatic's reactor shuts down and she dies
pixie lovemail
WHAT
Cute Quinn
skerple Emma? Emma is good
skerple
ye that one, I couldn't remember the name
pixie lovemail
BACK UP A MOMENT
AzureChrysanthemum
Yeah that explains Mahoromatic pretty much to a T
Cute Quinn
the final epiode jumps ten years into the future and the plucky kid protagonist is now a cyborg hunter with a lightsaber
skerple
basically that. the maid has some kind of actual medical condition that is interfering with her work and it hasn't occurred to her to ask for help/she doesn't think help is available
AzureChrysanthemum
He reunites with her reincarnated 16-year-old body and they have eternal love or something
pixie lovemail
what
skerple
.... what the fuck
Cute Quinn
I can't convey how unbelievably stupid mahoromatic is
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
what the fuck. yikes.
AzureChrysanthemum
Yeah it's
AzureChrysanthemum
Very bad
AzureChrysanthemum
We watched it in Anime club in college
Cute Quinn
anyway I remember 2 main things about Emma
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
yeah i'm gonna say there are basically two ways to go around it
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
either she's clumsy because she doesn't give a single shit
Cute Quinn
1. the omake episode about what if a generic anime maid was ported into Emma
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
or because she has an actual like, problem, causing problems with the work
Cute Quinn
where she's just following the master around going "master...💛"
Cute Quinn
and Emma's like "do your FUCKING job"
Cute Quinn
2. the mangaka's depiction of London is so historically accurate that there's a community of fans who suspect her of having occult powers
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
that's extremely good
pixie lovemail
now i'm curious about it too
Cute Quinn
Emma is, in fact, good
skerple
yeah the crunchyroulette was very kind to us that night
Cute Quinn
Master: "The new maid can be clumsy but she's trying her best, and I can't help but root for her"
Cute Quinn
Maid: /makes direct eye contact with the butler while emptying a bottle of tequila
RobotApocalypse
she's a catgirl with cerebellar hypoplasia
RobotApocalypse
no angst about being clumsy, just a down-to-earth acceptance of her limitations and an "oh well, it happens" attitude about breaking plates and spilling tea and tripping over her own feet and such
RobotApocalypse
(if you didn't know, this is the condition that "wobbly cats" have which makes them clumsy and uncoordinated but otherwise perfectly healthy)
🎄ndrusi
attempting to not duplicate any other suggestions: the maid is perfectly competent within the normal bounds of her job, but there's always Anime Nonsense going on so usually when she's onscreen she's knocking a vase over by accident because she got startled by an energy blast or something
🎄ndrusi
a giant robot bodychecks another giant robot into the side of the mansion and she falls over and spills tea everywhere
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
.... okay, you know what
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
i'm actually into that too
merry witchmas
a concept: maid is so clumsy bc of underlying medical condition. she knows being a maid is a suboptimal career for her but the pay is great
merry witchmas
oh andy I love yours lol
ғᴏxʏᴍᴏʀᴏɴ
"why didn't you dust the west wing today, maid"
"well, sir, i did, but immediately after i finished, the power rangers fired their finisher through the wall, scattering debris all over the area i just cleaned"
skerple
"oh. that's all right, then. I hope you weren't hurt."
🎄ndrusi
yes perfect
NekoInc, MSPM
The maid is specifically paid to be clumsy on cue to fuck with the master's guests. She is however legit terrible at one specific task that no one intends to leave her stuck with but it seems to happen way too often and people assume it's the same cue thing and not her being bad at it.
Makimerry🤶
I'm here in the Disabled Maid corner
the grink
I'm here for Food Service Quality "Doesn't Give A Shit" Maid
Dragomorph
i can't believe all of this is missing the obvious take on the clumsy bumbling maid:
Dragomorph
OCTOMAID
Dragomorph
nobody suspects a thing
skerple
omgggg
the grink
Dragomorph : bonus points if it's literally octodad in a maid outfit but nobody can recognize him in the wrong clothes
Cute Quinn
octomaid is choice
NekoInc, MSPM
Octodad's sister-in-law, Octomaid

Don't think about it too hard
🎄ndrusi
yeah I think octomaid wins
🎄ndrusi
I didn't think this was a competition but it must have been because we have a winner
載入新的回覆