So that JK Rowling tweet flushed out a load of pompous men and TRAs who think misgendering is a far worse crime than rape. It's good to know what these people's priorities are.
There are some areas in which biological sex matters, and rape stats are definitely one. Thank you for continuing to wake people up to these issues. sexmatters 在某些領域,生理性別很重要,強姦統計數據絕對是其中之一。感謝您繼續提醒人們注意這些問題。
That anyone ever has to refer to their rapist as a woman is the ultimate form of gaslighting. What a disgusting and deliberately traumatic thing to do to someone who has been subjected to rape. Yet again, the feelings of male offenders above all else.
It is because, in response to JKR latest tweet, you are now all falling over yourselves to prioritise the sensitivities of the rapist over the welfare of the woman he raped that we see you as the morally bankrupt idealogues you, in fact, are.
There's a reason why trans campaigners across the Western world have bent over backwards to avoid public scrutiny. Their agenda—including putting male rapists in women's prisons—isn't popular and their tactics are ugly, too.
The biggest drivers of public opposition to the trans agenda have always been trans activists themselves—their insane claims and demands, and their tantrums when they don't get their way.
If you're a self-identified progressive struggling to defend rapists against misgendering, you know you can sit this one out, right? You don't have to hop on Twitter and blast your solidarity with the trans community.
Let me help you out. She is saying that it is a purposeful display of male power to force women to accept that a male person who raped them with a penis is actually a woman.
The greatest trick the patriarchy ever pulled is convincing women and those who believe themselves to be feminists that the rights of men are more important than the rights of women.
'Woman' is not a costume. 'Woman' is not an idea in a man's head. The 'inclusive' language that calls female people 'menstruators' and 'people with vulvas' strikes many women as dehumanising and demeaning." — JK Rowling
"We're living through the most misogynistic period I've ever experienced. Never have I seen women denigrated and dehumanised to the extent they are now. 'Woman' is not an idea in a man's head."
J.K.羅琳對目前跨性別運動的批判
IStandWithJKRowling
《1984》反烏托邦小說裡面最重要的是「新語newspeak」與「雙重思想Doublethink」
我們看到,女人的語言與定義正在被奪走
我們看到,所有人都一本正經、服膺黨的意志在真誠的說謊
——戰爭即和平,自由即奴役,無知即力量
「男人也會懷孕」誠然為女人在做政治表達時插入的「奧威爾式廢話」(Orwellian Nonsense)
承認這一點,其他一切就迎刃而解。
-------
女人就是生物學上的女人
女人不是一種感覺、一種興趣、一種個人式的性幻想
因此,JK 羅琳的推文沖刷了大量自負的男人和 TRA,他們認為對強姦犯"用錯誤性別稱呼"是比強姦更嚴重的犯罪。很高興知道這些人的優先事項是什麼。
Classifying violent male offenders as female is state-sanctioned violence against women — both psychological and physical.
男性強姦犯正在被轉移到女子監獄,並且已經在美國、加拿大和英國強姦和毆打女性。
將暴力男性犯罪者歸類為女性是政府加諸於女性的國家暴力,同時在心理和身體上。
2.與強姦犯站在一起
很高興看到他們無法區分二者差異
在某些領域,生理性別很重要,強姦統計數據絕對是其中之一。感謝您繼續提醒人們注意這些問題。
Brilliant to expose this (JKR surely knew this was exactly how they'd react) but grim to watch it play out.
很高興揭露這一點(JKR 肯定知道這正是他們的反應),但很難看到它的發展。
西方世界的跨性別活動家為了逃避公眾的監督而向後彎腰是有原因的。他們的議程——包括將男性強姦犯關進女子監獄——並不受歡迎,他們的策略也很醜陋。
公眾反對跨性別議程的最大驅動力一直是跨性別活動家自己 - 他們瘋狂的主張和要求,以及他們在沒有得到自己的方式時發脾氣。
如果你是一個自我認同的進步主義者,努力為強姦犯辯護,防止性別認同錯稱,你知道你可以坐下來,對吧?您不必跳上 Twitter 並大肆宣揚您與跨性別社群的團結。
想想吧。
認真對待你的責任,瞭解你所支持的東西。想想你在哪裡劃清了界線,什麼會導致你從這場運動中撤回你的支援。想想你怎麼知道你是否在錯誤的地方畫了這條線。
And the demonstration is that it utterly fucks women over.
If a 'basic right' forces women to pretend their male rapist is a woman it can't be a 'basic right.'
示範是它完全在惡搞女人。
如果一項“基本權利”是強迫女性假裝她們的男性強姦犯是女性,那它就不能是“基本權利”。
Rape is the most male crime of all.
強姦是所有男性犯罪中最多的。
J.K.羅琳相信性別sex是真實的,男性暴力是個問題,女人需要用清楚的語言討論自己的問題、沒有女人應該因為自我意見表達失去工作。
沒有令人信服的評論可以告訴我們,為什麼相信以上這些事會傷害跨性別族群?
另外一篇2020年報導集結討論,告訴我們,在J.K羅琳推特下面的極端跨性別運動者,只是極端自我中心且不關心他人及公眾事物,一如往常。
方便處在於,它的網站有一鍵中文翻譯,要找外電報導非常方便且迅速
得到更多的是Orwellian廢話:ex你傷了跨性別族群的感情跟尊嚴
男人聲稱他們是男人,於是政府及法制全盤接受(或一起說謊假裝)
女人否認他們是女人,社會並不在乎她們的意見並攻擊她們「恐跨症」
沒有什麼比這更「父權」的表現了
letting rape suspects self-identify as women has dangers, admits justice secretary Keith Brown
父權制有史以來最大的伎倆是說服女性和那些認為自己是女權主義者的人,男性的權利比女性的權利更重要。
昨天、今天和明天: IStandWithJKRowling
archive.md
Sexual offending: Crown Prosecution Service appendix...
「女人」不是男人腦子裡的想法。
將女性稱為「月經人」和「有外陰的人」的”包容性”語言讓許多女性感到毫無人性和貶低。
Yet in reality, it is women who are erased by gender ideology.
但實際上,被性別意識形態抹殺的卻是女性。
新聞標題:《JK 羅琳因更多恐跨症指控被從《怪獸與牠們的產地》預告片中“刪除”》
Never have I seen women denigrated and dehumanised to the extent they are now.
'Woman' is not an idea in a man's head."
— JK Rowling
“我們正經歷著我所經歷過的最厭惡女性的時期。
我從未見過女性像現在這樣被貶低和非人化。
「女人」不是男人腦子裡的想法。"