Endings are tricky because we expect answers. Fifteen years ago, with my first film Saving Face, I got one recurring question: “Is this ending… too happy?”
At the time, as much as I saw the truth in it for my characters, I confessed to not knowing if that happy ending could be expected in real life; but as a queer woman, I wanted - needed - to see it in order to believe it could happen for me.
Now with The Half Of It I’m regularly peppered with questions over whether certain characters end up together in an ever-pointed crescendo toward “But is the ending happy?” (Ha!)
My honest answer is that the point of the film isn’t about who ends up with whom. It’s about three people who collide in a moment-in-time before going their separate ways, each now holding the piece of themselves that allows them to become the person they are meant to be.
Wow oh 導演po了給三個主角的playlists 其中Alexxis的歌單還說明:”I gave Alexxis Lemire this playlist the day before we started shooting. "For the young woman looking for her place in the world. Songs to be added per shoot day."
沙加緬度的少女們是否每個都能拍一部YA片(不
------------------------------------
如果原初人真的有和自己相連的另一半,我覺得神更惡趣味一些的話,真相可能是祂告訴人們祂所拆散的半身在世界的某處,讓人終生尋覓,但其實祂壓根沒拆散人的半身,祂只是把那個半身藏起來讓每個人都看不到、感覺不到自己原來身上的另一半。
而人以為看不到就等於失去,於是深信不疑盲目地向外追尋半身,完全沒發現自己其實從來都是完整的,始終以為自己有所欠缺。
Complete/Love 不是找到一個人結合就能順利法喜充滿的結果,而是需要不斷trying reaching falling的過程,毀掉好的畫作,換取機會成為最好的自己
我就是看不爽半身理論太過單一化歧視單身狗老師這篇報告我沒收錢請打A+謝謝私揣測Aster的心境,身為一個生於沙加緬度的第二代墨西哥裔美國人,舉家搬來一個傳統保守9成以上白人居住的小鎮,房子還是租來的。她跟Ellie的背景是如此相似,而且她大概從Ellie來教會幫忙彈琴的時候開始就關注她了,或許甚至更早。撇除Aster的美麗讓她與眾不同外,她與Ellie都有因為身世背景的不同而格格不入,但相較Eliie擺明不融入的態度,Aster採取強迫自己抽離以融入當地文化的策略,這或許也跟她來自於一個家父長式的家庭有關。
而我看Ellie打從一開始就是喜歡人家,目光追隨那麼熱切,第一次跟人家有所互動還腦袋空白到只蹦出一句自我介紹XDDDD(事後還覺得自己太蠢生氣XDDD)只是她太退卻了不敢承認而已
而當晚Aster同樣問Paul信不信神,Paul說信,然後Aster吻了他
她一開始其實和Paul很強調這只是朋友關係(好像還講了兩三次),但後頭和Ellie的文字神交真的太深入太美好(乾),才讓她慢慢淪陷。
一個人可以在跟本人相處時,以及與他文字交談時,帶給人的感覺能那麼不同嗎?
Aster在溫泉約會後,在當晚與Paul的相處時肯定是帶著這個困惑問出那個信神的問題,她其實在試探。她那時吻了Paul,代表的不是她選擇相信這個人,而是她選擇了安全感,畢竟誰需要自由?那裏面沒有用力擁抱和被依賴等等安全感(突然1976#
話說劇本裡明確寫到Aster有回吻 owwww....
下意識揩油ㄟ XDDDDDDDDDDD
然後booksmart游泳那段真的是很magic配樂也超讚這個小動作到底喔XDDD 有膽偷偷揩油沒膽正面上 Ellie Chu U useless lesbian!!!(x
booksmart那段真的超神ㄉqqqq配樂畫面完美契合qqqq
雖然都很有戲 但互動能更多一點就好了嗚嗚嗚嗚
分析得太好...想再去重看被甜一把
雖然電影裡甜的畫面不多,但我已經可以想像Ellie之後名正言順地跟Aster傳文青簡訊順帶練習傳鳳梨、貓頭鷹、戴眼鏡的毛毛蟲的相處了(疑
看完之後瘋狂腦補她們真的在一起時,那些既細膩又甜蜜的互動
而且看劇中明明就是很正常的在聊天,還是活生生被甜死了
老師表示真的沒辦法再看其他的爛報告了,由奢入儉難
而且老師知道代寫情書的事的時候,還有點責怪Ellie「不務正業」實在很妙XDD
It's not a happy ending, it's a happy beginning.
“Aster Flores can stroke me boldly any day she wants . I don't even know what that means but you get what i mean “
所以可以直線判定她們的愛情穩了對吧也許她們變得不再像以前一樣感到寂寞。但在某個時刻仍然會想起彼此所共處的點點滴滴,像那些私密的信件、一同完成的壁畫、夜半無眠的簡訊、一同仰望的天空等等,那些除彼此之外無人知曉的浮光掠影。
其實就算未來她們沒有在一起(虐屁),只要想到她們曾有那樣深的靈魂共鳴,不能說隨隨便便就斷開的連結,還是覺得...啊......好萌
不過我邊看邊想到......在兩個人肉體(?)的相處之中,Aster她其實已經trying、reaching,努力向Ellie靠近,不過因為Ellie心中有鬼太過被動,所以Aster的那些試探與靠近在後來種種誤會下就falling了
讀眼神真是一門重要的學問XDD
“two girls, chilling in a hot spring, five feet apart ‘cause they’re very gay”
- Alice Wu
導演 謝謝妳給我們的happy beginnings
溫泉給兩個人加的os也好好笑wwwwwwww
其中Alexxis的歌單還說明:”I gave Alexxis Lemire this playlist the day before we started shooting. "For the young woman looking for her place in the world. Songs to be added per shoot day."
愛P跟Z的教學