Seijin CC
State of the CC -- In MA! I haz a new laptop! old one is melting and so fucking hot :V I haz pizza but as with laptop: not the capacity to set it up ayyyyyy
Seijin CC
for some reason my phone won't charge while plugged into laptop [old] so I gotta go... get it. And go back to bed. And get night meds. also my lymph system is trying to murder me. holy cow
Seijin CC
I thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiink?????????????????????????????????? I may have semi-successfully explained the hardest parts of my Economic upgrade to my Dad???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Seijin CC
need more question marks :V
Seijin CC
it did devolve into hours of fighting and yelling like I warned it would because we both get crazy frustrated with our inabilities to properly express what we mean in a way the other can latch on
Seijin CC
This was prompted by Moosey telling Jason to talk to me but ironically where Jason was talking about UBI and what he's calling the "fifth estate" [church, nobility, labor, media / people on UBI and or "others" aka: those who buy because automation is inevitable]
Seijin CC
I was trying to explain why I don't like that, and how we could in fact employ people who otherwise are seen as incapable
Seijin CC
ie: instead of just I buy therefore I contribute
Seijin CC
actually helping save other people time and reviewing things and product testing and explorers/curators etc. etc.
Seijin CC
/f a l l s over
Seijin CC
We did eventually wake up mom with the yelling
Seijin CC
lmfao HILARIOUSLY TO ME
Seijin CC
Luffy-bro of all people understood it easiest
Seijin CC
and was helping me try to explain it back
Seijin CC
did not see that coming lol
Seijin CC
though it always reassures me when ANYONE ELSE GETS IT
Seijin CC
and of course Dad tends to go Devil's advocate where he's like "Okay I get it but what if someone else--" and I go mad because I'm like
Seijin CC
"No. You can't artificially portray to me someone else's argument because then I can't tell if I'm progressing and what I said made sense to get there. Stop."
Seijin CC
which I get is really hard for him because that's how he straight up THINKS
Seijin CC
in terms of how other people see things; but that is like the thing I am blind at. I can only trust what people say and/or work through it like math problems; show me step by step where you tripped up so I can see what I explained poorly.
Seijin CC
I wonder if I should sleep or try to get pizza and -- no fuck it def. sleep. I cannot get my body to move enough to get in the car again even for pokemon XDDD
Seijin CC
okay bbl o/
Exacerangutan
I still hold that in full post-scarcity circumstances, an economy that mandates labor is problematic at best, but
Seijin CC
it doesn't mandate but it does encourage it by reconcieving "labor" since sharing and generating data is part of it
Exacerangutan
I was discussing this with my brothers when I was down in Texas, so it's been on my mind, because they came at it from different angles than I'd considered before (which is why discussion with a lot of people is important!!!!)
Seijin CC
yay
Seijin CC
!!!
Exacerangutan
I think their main concern was
Exacerangutan
in a work-optional post-scarcity society, the people who do work would be bitter towards the people who don't feel compelled to at the moment
Exacerangutan
unless they were somehow given drastically different life opportunities of some kind
Exacerangutan
...the way they talked about it sounded almost like separation into castes
Seijin CC
that's the problem I have with UBI
Exacerangutan
...which... I guess some might, but I feel like that's mainly scarcity-based thinking. >_> Which obviously is still a habit that's with us now, but
Exacerangutan
in a truly post-scarcity society, it doesn't
Exacerangutan
cost you anything that someone else is surviving
Seijin CC
ya
Exacerangutan
it would be like getting angry at deer for not financing the EPA
Exacerangutan
besides which, while I'm all for some compensation for labor when it's no longer obligatory, I feel like the main drive toward labor is
Exacerangutan
wanting to do things
Seijin CC
yes that is what it is moreover
Seijin CC
sharing things
Seijin CC
look
Exacerangutan
I mean I'm seeing this from a scientist point of view
Seijin CC
I'll explain it better next chapter outline
𝔯𝔞𝔦𝔫𝔟𝔬𝔴 𝔭𝔦𝔯𝔞𝔠𝑦~
gddamn those deer I knew they were shifty bastards
𝔯𝔞𝔦𝔫𝔟𝔬𝔴 𝔭𝔦𝔯𝔞𝔠𝑦~
/shot
Exacerangutan
that if I could survive comfortably without working
Seijin CC
lmao
Seijin CC
exactly
Seijin CC
no wait
Seijin CC
okay yes
Seijin CC
I think?
Seijin CC
keep going orz
Exacerangutan
....I would still do at least 3/4 as much work as I do, and maybe more, because I wouldn't be worrying about finances and job searching and so on
Exacerangutan
forcing people to do things can sometimes squeeze some more productivity out of them, but IMO mainly it gets them to burn out faster
Seijin CC
it's not force
Seijin CC
it's letting people find their own bliss
Exacerangutan
...I mean if it's "do the thing or you will be homeless and sick and hungry" it's force
Seijin CC
no
Seijin CC
we're post scarcity remember?
Exacerangutan
right but if the only access to necessary resources is through labor
Exacerangutan
even in post-scarcity, you can have manufactured scarcity
Exacerangutan
//gestures at the Cardassians//
Seijin CC
right which is why I'm pre-empting it
Seijin CC
also
Seijin CC
dude
Exacerangutan
I mean it usually ends up requiring fascism in extreme cases, but
Seijin CC
Robbie's little snores are soooooooooooooooo cute
Exacerangutan
Robbie? o.o
Seijin CC
Moosey said he never saw him so in love with someone that everytime he sees me he jumps on all things to come cuddle and kiss me lol
Seijin CC
Mom's service dog
Seijin CC
he's under her chair and snoring
Exacerangutan
ohhh
Exacerangutan
XD
Seijin CC
the rest of us are watching The good place
Seijin CC
no like Jason was talking about the five estates
Seijin CC
but the problem with all of that is that it's still about ownership of goods
Seijin CC
my Dad was talking about automation being replacement for work but he was saying how
Seijin CC
when industrialization etc. replaced agriculture as labor
Seijin CC
there was a new product [clothes etc/ "stuff"] that was being made and that more people than just the rare wealthy could obtain
Seijin CC
but that there wouldn't be one now
Seijin CC
and I disagreed
Seijin CC
because what the new "stuff" is; is yet more art/media/games/gaming, "time"
Seijin CC
and that all labour is in essence about time
Seijin CC
and my Dad was frustrated that he doesn't even want to look at his email inbox because there's too much spam etc.
Seijin CC
and it's like me and Steam
Seijin CC
I have nearly 7000 games and no capacity to really in depth play them all etc.
Seijin CC
so people adequately expressing and saving each other time and bringing each other enjoyment IS the new stuff and important
Seijin CC
and it's like service dogs
Exacerangutan
Seijin CC
yes you have pets, but service dogs are also more stable and happy, not just because of training, but because they are satisfied to be doing something that helps and gives that feeling of accomplishment
Seijin CC
and indeed
Seijin CC
one of the training things for dogs that mess up a whole neighborhood is to take them around and do a St. Bernard thing, of having them bring water bottles and things to people
Exacerangutan
I don't quite follow how this addresses the ground-level argument that making labor a requisite for basic living conditions is inconsistent with a post-scarcity society >_>
Seijin CC
no it's not!!!!
Seijin CC
you are automatically guaranteed housing, food, etc. because you are automatically part of humanity and generate data and it's necessary to incorporate that data and etc.
Exacerangutan
flailing and yelling no doesn't actually address it either! -_-
Exacerangutan
wh-
Exacerangutan
.......hrmn.
Seijin CC
/huff
Exacerangutan
so the counter-argument is that
Exacerangutan
by existing
Exacerangutan
and interacting with the world/marketplaces/etc at all
Exacerangutan
you generate data of sufficient value to offset your costs of living?
Seijin CC
yes!!! in post-scarcity yes
Seijin CC
and indeed
Seijin CC
that your interactions etc. are part of it ->
Seijin CC
but you can opt out it too etc.
Seijin CC
and pave your own way if it pleases you etc.
Seijin CC
just as I was saying you could opt to request for "explorers" to come see your stuff and if they like it, spread the word and shit etc.
Seijin CC
and my Dad was confused like "why would anyone not"
Exacerangutan
sorry I'm puzzled because it sounds like you said the same thing I said, but added "but that's OK because you pay by contributing to national statistics" XD
Exacerangutan
which... I'm not sure the value of a person's data is really high enough for that to be an economic factor, but
Seijin CC
= Mister Metokur. He doesn't want to deal with the hassle of too many people, monetizing his shit, making videos for money instead of fun etc.
Seijin CC
I mean ther'es more into it, but you aren't forced to create labor period. the problem is we still need to reform what we acknowledge as useful and "labor" to society like
Seijin CC
watching things etc.
Exacerangutan
that is true as well
Exacerangutan
the difference between a high-quality LP and a professional critic's review is that the LP may be totally unpaid but actually shows you the game through the lens of someone who demonstrably knows what they're talking about
Exacerangutan
although monetization means less good LPs are unpaid, but
Seijin CC
also pros are paid for by special interests so it needs more removal
載入新的回覆