🏍️不可能的社畜
: Susan Wendell的The Rejected Body 她是女性主義哲學家,後來成為了長期病患於是套用了一些女性主義到身障人士的哲學議題,很豐富但每章都很厚我得很用力地嚼XD我剛好在讀到第四章就是談女性身體和殘疾身體在文化中理想的身體(ideals)、正常的身體(normal)、被拒絕的身體(被定義為"abnormal"而被拒絕的身體-The rejected body書的標題)之間的差異是如何造成的
That’s what’s so frustrating about the film - the intentions are there, the bare bones exist. The women are in charge, the chosen messiah is a woman. It’s almost progressive, it has the makings to be more.
There are a wealth of female characters in Blade Runner 2049, and at least a couple are complex, dramatic creations. (I’m sure Robin Wright’s no-nonsense Lt. Joshi has some hot takes about the state of outdoor advertising that she’d share over a whiskey or two.)
But Villeneuve’s film is ultimately obsessed with motherhood and the ability to reproduce over any other defining female trait, and feels less interested in questions of consciousness than in the pursuit of an elusive pseudo-religious special baby.
This is not a film that was ever going to be interested in anything but familiar, even old-fashioned sexual politics, and I don’t want to spend too much time criticizing Villeneuve for his performance in a game he clearly wasn’t even playing.
I just mean to point out that his use of female bodies as figureheads, these massive gaping-mouthed infertility idols, are not empty or neutral creative choices.
感性地:畫面和世界觀很大氣多看一點也沒關係
理智地:片長真的…很……長………
我跟我朋友是去看早場,我看到差點睡著(爆),不過真的是滿冷硬的片,喜歡的人大概會很喜歡吧XD
自己也覺得很累,用這些角度來看電影大概就是喪失了融入電影的樂趣吧?另外,說到生育的部分我在腦裡跟MMFR做了比較XD
唉就更別提盲人是惡役這刻板設定了沒有才很奇怪Deckard說出有時候愛人就是要像一個陌路人……我內心:幹麼要在這部裡洗白缺失的父親形象啊XDDDDDDDDDDD感覺權利&權力就是有偏見啊
畢竟在大停電之前,女兒是在城外的孤兒院裡,德克本身並沒有特別要將女兒放在玻璃箱中,只是他若真的是複製人(假設他已經自我懷疑),那當時的警方要定位他的位置應該很簡單(沒人想到會有大停電造成絕大多數資料損毀),因此離開女兒確實是最決斷的方法(沒有後顧之憂)
Ana那段我也覺得是用來強調她與Wallace平等的地位(可以拒絕對方),且也映照出雖然她出生的方式與仿生人不同,但她的孤單卻與其他仿生人一樣重。