Ex-ocolonist
https://64.media.tumblr.com/e10502a08a56494236996a88f3e79a4e/169bccfc28f7abd2-9e/s2048x3072/94300dd159c6f43f3e752a17111e6cd2455a7e99.jpg mecha fans of plurk, thoughts
—Kami
Bokurano was WILD
💀 BONE DADDY
not enough Braves series on there
💀 BONE DADDY
... I JUST SAW RATATOULLIE ON THERE LMFAO
—Kami
I'd probs put 86 right down the bottom of gritty though, god damn broke my heart - the world is so ruthless
—Kami
RATATOULLIE?! 🤣
Str8 Kaworu
Eva should be more super robot
💀 BONE DADDY
it's in the top left
💀 BONE DADDY
tiny tiny little picture
—Kami
OMG HAHAHA
—Kami
Does pluto count as a mecha cause their robots?! or is mecha just like BIG robots
Str8 Kaworu
Also I'd move gunbuster down on gritty and TTGL up on pop
—Kami
OH YEAH! Guren Lagan all the way up to pop!!
Str8 Kaworu
TTGL being more put as more gritty than gunbuster baffles me
Ramases II
Same. Likewise Geese being more Super than Zone of the Enders
Ramases II
There's definitely like, a Spectrum in both, but Metatron is straight up magic
ᴠɪᴄᴛᴏʀʏ ɢᴏᴅᴅᴇss
bokurano 💜💜💜💜💜💜
ᴠɪᴄᴛᴏʀʏ ɢᴏᴅᴅᴇss
uhhh i swear i have more thoughts- i think it'd be cool to slot the various gundams on here in comparison to each other but i haven't seen enough of them to do so
Ramases II
They're all over the right and middle of the map tbh
MaxSalsa
FMP needs another position for "where Sousuke thinks it is" and it just moves straight down.
second banana 🍌
the lone nadesico liker has entered the chat
second banana 🍌
I'm fascinated that it's somehow less pop than geass??? which I always forget has mechs lmao
second banana 🍌
yaoi blinders
Odd-Eyes
smh wheres symphogear/j
Odd-Eyes
...DOES ATTACK ON TITAN COUNT??? WHATS THAT DOIN THERE
(it's a helmet)
what is "pop"
(it's a helmet)
Odd-Eyes : I mean I guess if Ratatouille counts as a mecha show AoT titans are just fleshy mechs
(it's a helmet)
It's really stretching it in a taco-is-sandwich way
Odd-Eyes
pffffffffft
(it's a helmet)
more amused that apparently AoT titans are more "super robot" than Ideon, the robot literally capable of unmaking half of the entire universe
(it's a helmet)
Ramases II : also re the various Gundams, I feel like G is the only one that steps over into the Super Robot side of the spectrum, just enough to be noticed
(it's a helmet)
Like ZoE levels of "on the super side" if that, but still more than the rest of the franchise sitting right about where the UC spot there is
(it's a helmet)
(Turn A is a weird outlier there because the actual titular gundam is absolutely a super in-context but 99.9% of the suits there are incredibly real)
Ramases II
Judau's brand of newtype bullshit and Crossbone's general tone are responsible for the UC rep in the middle third
Ramases II
I'd also put 00 there by the movie at least
Ramases II
CE is what happens when a director who's only seen the left quarter of the chart aims for something near the bottom right and misses
Ramases II
I have no idea where it actually lands
expired milk
yeah most of this scans
expired milk
second banana 🍌 : excuse you i have a yurika journal
Ramases II
Yeah Nadesico was also my first mecha show. I've spent the rest of my anime liker career watching other mecha shows so I could understand the jokes
second banana 🍌
expired milk : HELLO?? THATS SO RAD
second banana 🍌
that makes me so happy 😭 I love that program
expired milk
yeah i played her in airlocked and srwq!
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
see i disagree with gridman's placement but mostly bc i think it's a false dichotomy
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
like it very much is Like That but also it's fucking denpa.
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
i think battletech can't actually be as cool and gritty as it wants to be because the setting is so bonkers stupid send tweet
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
get aot off of here.
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
aldnoah zero is dead center which is appropriate since the show has nothing to say
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
uhhhh
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
+1 on whatever's going on with gunbuster and ttgl
expired milk
yeah like aot is very "if evangelion counts this counts" but like. that's a massive spoiler
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
eh
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
i think eva inarguably counts just bc of the genre it's clearly working within
how about no
I am shocked that big O is not on there
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
honestly i'd put ttgl like. half-overlapping ggg and promare if it was me
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
but i guess there's the tone switch there
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
uhhhh dial macross further to the left probably, it being basically as real as patlabor feels Wrong
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
sorry im on a tear now
expired milk
yeah true
i don't even like attack on titan but /shrug
expired milk
it's kinda like the mecha equivalent of the Corrector Yui line but in reverse
(it's a helmet)
i think i get what you're putting down with battletech, like it wants to be armored core but unfortunately, like... FASA sure had FASA brain and both battletech and shadowrun are astoundingly stupid in their eagerness to be gritty
expired milk
(the Corrector Yui line being a metric for magical girls as to whether something "counts" even when it's all explained with advanced technology)
(it's a helmet)
actually speaking about things being "counted" on how technically-true vs spiritually-true makes me wonder

we got fucking dunbine and aot here

forget symphogear where's fucking rayearth
(it's a helmet)
(don't forget symphogear, but like. it and rayearth are brothers in "magical girl series make the best mecha anime" mentality)
second banana 🍌
how about no
magic knight rayearth also being missing is weird but I guesssssss people can say that's a stretch
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
generally the reference pools on this thing are. weird. to me
expired milk
Yeah, I feel like MKR is isekai with mecha elements (and light magical girl elements, but some people count it as a straight-up magical girl anime).
expired milk
But it does have mecha, so we can count it.
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
it's mecha enough to be in two super robot wars games
ʟɪʟɪᴍ ʜᴀʀʟᴏᴛ
no greater mark of counting than that
(it's a helmet)
yeah it counts at least as much as big o by the "in SRW" metric
(it's a helmet)
as much as IBO too
(it's a helmet)
which is just deadass a Gundam
(it's a helmet)
that said I will admit I was mixing things up when I called it magical girl; i mandela effect'd myself, it's just girls that are magical, not magical girl
(it's a helmet)
i forgot it was one of the First Wave of isekai manga/anime alongside el hazard and fushigi yuugi
expired milk
Eh, some people classify it that way. Some people also call Utena magical girl, whereas I wouldn't really, but.
(it's a helmet)
utena absolutely employs magical girl tools to make its points, like it has transformation sequences and monster-of-the-day combat pacing despite the combats being anything but motd
Gayple
me squinting looking for the big o
(it's a helmet)
honestly I feel like Big O should be where Evangelion is, but for ENTIRELY DIFFERENT REASONS
Gayple
all of this is good shit though, hell yeah mecha
DoveEaterXC
.....okay pacrim is definitely more pop than that
Odd-Eyes
magical girls make the best mecha...
Odd-Eyes
I think if it managed to get into SRW then it deserves its time of day on the chart, so seriously where is Rayearth...
DoveEaterXC
tbf we can't add everything otherwise /mashes dozens of 70s/early 80s shows into the left half until it's just a pile of primary colors
載入新的回覆