glenna
glenna
part 1這篇太長,part 2還是另外發一篇,不過只能說滿失望的,可能前半真的讓我太喜歡跟期待了
glenna
glenna
https://images.plurk.com/pu9K7UIzGdqTOZpeVCvSb.jpg
忍不住重看書中結局這段,Colin像眾人炫耀自己的老婆,並揭露Pen是Lady Whistledown,真的比劇中呈現好太多....
現在劇這樣亂改後,我想要收藏小說了...
glenna
https://images.plurk.com/T263KRW79FllDIeiGpDod.jpg
還有這段肉麻告白也消失了....
glenna
. My biggest let down was the love confession we didn’t get. Sure, Colin standing up for pen to her mother and blurting it out was nice and after prudence and Phillipas ball, but nothing like the confession we got from the book. We got Daphne and Anthony’s love confessions, but not polins which in my opinion, was the best confession from all the books.
glenna
https://images.plurk.com/gvXBlemCD67amaY9cTZXk.png
社團有人跟我一樣想法QQ
glenna
劇版第二部真的弱化Colin角色很多,小說裡在舞會公開Pen是LW明明是他的想法啊,結果劇裡他跑去跟Cressida溫情喊話也太弱 = =
glenna
劇裡Pen跟原生家庭的和解是很動人,但我覺得反而更不符合現實,長期這樣忽視甚至鄙視她的家人怎麼可能一夕改變,書裡她轉而在婆家找到溫暖還比較合理一點....
glenna
總之前半我喜歡劇>小說(馬車戲劇版呈現較好),後半則小說>劇
glenna
https://images.plurk.com/4YswXX7ARkxfwHOkDdIcDM.png https://images.plurk.com/7E20gIumlIHlyTNNYLyrEM.png https://images.plurk.com/55v40l90TiIyTBAij2YZR.png
shinyi大對Polin是真愛吧
glenna
我也覺得Cressida劇版洗白太多,上半部那種程度還可以接受,但下半部就有點硬要...
glenna
給個系列評分:外傳>S3>>>>S2>>S1
glenna
然後F跟B這樣改之後,我已經對下季毫無期待(雖然我沒看他們的書但也覺得在主角家庭加上LGBT戲分很不對勁),所以下季滿有可能不會繼續看了...
glenna
https://images.plurk.com/1Y0QeLK3wmn1AXsZMGJPsQ.png
這點也是我困惑的地方,既然這樣幹嘛要讓John在這季登場,還把他們的戀愛線做得這麼討喜,結果讓F才剛結婚就精神出軌嗎....那還不如像書一樣把John當背景就好
glenna
https://images.plurk.com/3ReX3106doi7bGq1sGYpZb.jpg https://images.plurk.com/5TK8je789hMY1k3wYClMgr.jpg
這對真的好可愛XDD
載入新的回覆