BNL and Todd Rundgren have been on my heavy-rotation list since I was bitty, so there's two down.

High school was before I discovered Andrew Bird.

Coldplay.

Can't remember if Belle & Sebastian was high school or college.

The Who is another old standard.

...not actually sure about a fifth that's unique to high school. That's about the time I had my '80s phase, but that wasn't any one band in particular.

The tapes that lived in my Walkman until I upgraded to a portable CD player: Erasure (The Innocents) and Weird Al In 3-D.