Master Chieve
So having played Bloodborne and (2/3rds of) Dark Souls I wanna talk about the design philosophy of these games with people who heard about it and thought it sounded pretentious and miserable
Master Chieve
Because I know that my impression of the FromSoftware Soulslike games before I started playing was that they’re long and grueling and miserable and full of unfair traps and ambushes so that you can have bragging rights if you manage to finish the game
Master Chieve
This is...partially true?
Master Chieve
They are very long and hard games
Master Chieve
Parts of them are even grueling
Master Chieve
But I would not describe them as hard for the sake of being hard
Quinneapolis
Dark Souls wants you to suffer before you win, but it DOES want you to eventually win
Master Chieve
The way the game plays out is that you WILL die a lot
Master Chieve
But
Master Chieve
You don’t really lose much when you die
Master Chieve
So sometimes yes you’ll get blindsided by a trap or an ambush and die
Master Chieve
But then, like
Master Chieve
You know about it
Master Chieve
So next time you’ll be able to deal with it
Master Chieve
The game is FULL of tiny little victories
Master Chieve
As you constantly push forward a little bit at a time
Quinneapolis
honestly I'm not sure any of the traps in sen's really fatally blindsided you
Master Chieve
And make little bits of hard progress that can’t be taken from you
Master Chieve
You died but you got a new sword
Quinneapolis
it rewards tenacity
Master Chieve
You died but you figured out how to beat a new kind of guy
Master Chieve
You died but you’ll be able to dodge that trap next time
Master Chieve
Most of your defeats are accompanied by you thinking “okay that hurt but I can get it next time”
Master Chieve
“I know what I did wrong”
Master Chieve
They’re definitely games that aren’t for everyone
Master Chieve
Except for Ornstein and Smough
Master Chieve
Fuck those guys
oh i'm scary
that's no way to talk about a lady
BF
This is also core to the themes of the game
BF
Giving up and rage quitting is what it means to Go Hollow
★ тяу-нαя∂уи
as somone who doesn't play soulsborne for reasons utterly unrelated to the gameplay, it's always seemed to me like the core of it is 'presenting you with a difficult puzzle but also the tools to solve it'
★ тяу-нαя∂уи
it's still fuckoff hard, but it appears designed to be less about the difficulty itself and more 'how to deal with that'
連続犬
that's correct yeah
★ тяу-нαя∂уи
sage nod
連続犬
a lot of the big dark souls setpiece bosses are a puzzle
★ тяу-нαя∂уи
(i have a crippling fear of spiders else i'd at least play bloodborne)
連続犬
because invariably when you run into a boss that's legitimately difficult
連続犬
your response is to go
連続犬
"okay, how do i deal with THIS attack"
連続犬
"THIS is what keeps killing me"
Quinneapolis
this is part of why sekiro didn't work for me
連続犬
"how do I solve that"
★ тяу-нαя∂уи
i think the 'teaching you how to use an important tool that will help us later' thing i like the most is literally just, like, asylum demon
Quinneapolis
because 'what did I do wrong' is always 'you didn't fight good enough, fight better'
★ тяу-нαя∂уи
'you are up here. he is down there. you have a sword and legs what jump.'
連続犬
Sekiro is definitely a much narrower niche of tools and is a bit more brutal as a result
連続犬
I like it but pretty much if you aren't here for the main gameplay loop of "parry then counter" you are going to have a MISERABLE time
oh i'm scary
it bothers me so much that the tagline for Sekiro was "kill ingeniously"
oh i'm scary
when it is, objectively
oh i'm scary
out of the Fromsoft Souls-Adjacent Games
oh i'm scary
the game to which it least applies
連続犬
fromsoft's games have had, shall we say
連続犬
a recurring theme of missing the mark in terms of marketing
oh i'm scary
you have one way to kill things and a handful of extremely limited-use ways to make it marginally easier
oh i'm scary
and anyway yeah the core gameplay is incredibly satisfying when you do it right but I've never played a game that more badly needed to be easier
Master Chieve
Anyway I cannot express how excited I am for Elden Ring
Master Chieve
Just for the experience of playing one of these games when it’s new
Master Chieve
I’ll be right in there with everyone else!
Master Chieve
We’ll figure this shit out TOGETHER
EsperBot
hell yeah
載入新的回覆