yes, the thing I love more than talking about how stupid star trek can be is talking about how existentially terrified Thomas Riker makes me aka the great "does the transporter actually kill you" debate
Remember when they got Diane Diane to write an episode for them and then completely rewrote her script into unrecognizability and the end result was terrible
(Word from Diane Duane’s mouth on a podcast she guested on is that only one line of dialogue and one action cue from her original script for Where No Man Has Gone Before actually made it into the episode)
Dude, remember when the holodeck just accidentally spit out a sentient life form and no one took it offline until they figure out why it happened. Then another hologram became sentient and no one said ‘whoa, let’s step back and rethink this holotechnology, as it seems to keep creating sentient life forms and we don’t know why’
Imagine if the same thing happened with biological organisms. You’re trying to use the replicator to get you a slab of targ meat and suddenly the replicator malfunctions and just spits out a fully sentient new life form, no one knows why
I guess accidentally creating sentient life forms in the future is no big, which makes it all the more weird they are in such a conundrum about Data’s personhood, when it seems this is a thing that keeps happening in the universe, and you’d except someone would assign some government somebody to be responsible for sorting it out
What’s terrible for the writing for both Dr. Crusher and Troi is that they both have compelling backstories that are hardly ever mentioned or explored, and then when we get an episode featuring them, the theme is often ‘a weird sex thing happens’. I mean sometimes it’s like getting impregnated by an energy force in your sleep, other times it’s getting off
your grandma’s ghost sex lantern, but then there’s also when you sex up a dude that turns out to have a parasite inside who wears your coworker’s body and then turns into a women, sexing up a skeevy dude who wants you to run away with him, getting targeted by a psychic vampire who makes you all horny, etc etc
I mean, Dr. Crusher was born on the moon, then moved to a colony where apparently the ‘technology failed’ and it was ‘horrible what happened there’ according to captain Picard and they ran out of normal medical supplies, so she actually has this background of privation and moving from having everything to a place where it was difficult to survive, which is
the thing that bothered me most about holograms is that the implication from Voyager is basically that they just slapped a patch on them that prevents them from realizing they are fictional if they become self aware, but otherwise still lets it happen
man that is the one thing that star trek books do better, i have a book somewhere around here that focuses primarily on keiko and troi and it really lets them shine in a way they rarely get to on screen.
Picard: "Mr. Worf."
Worf: "Ensign."
Ensign: steps forward and immediately eats shit