makiki-join lang po sa topic since i love HP. kung totoo nga yan theory na yan, hindi pa rin po nadiscredit si Hermione, kasi she still took the time finding out kung san dumadaan yung basilisk. she wrote "pipes" on that ripped piece of paper malfoy supposedly planted on her, kung papaniwalaan natin yung theory.
pero yan theory na yan sa.movie lang pwede i-apply, kasi sa books wala naman na mention tungkol sa pag punit ni malfoy ng book nung nag meet sila nina harry sa shop. also, in the books, hermione tends to break rules, as much as harry and ron. remember polyjuice potion? maybe that's why she's in griffindor. griffindors are known rule breakers/risk takers.