碎一地蘚苔
觀後碎念 《二十世紀的她們》( 20th Century Women)
“Wondering if you’re happy is a great shortcut to just being depressed.”
碎一地蘚苔
我最初其實不知道這是Mike Mills的片XDD 但電影一開始,我就:Beginners!!
不是啊這表現的pattern太固定了吧XD 不過,我就是超愛他的這個pattern,我很開心(
碎一地蘚苔
Pattern從最形式上的:幻燈片式地播放老相片/ 角色唸的旁白/ 標籤式的形容一個角色或年代
一直到概念上的:一個游刃有餘的酷老媽在人生上其實有很多的「失敗」以及不知所措,以及一個整體而言比較內向的兒子,兩者有著某種程度上的親密,母親卻又有所保留的狀態。加上一個難以捉模的女孩子。
碎一地蘚苔
不過我自己比較喜歡Beginners,覺得它的敘事更加地細膩,安排極度順暢以致不著痕跡(但可以知道導演巧心安排了大量細節)。《20世紀》前段就讓我覺得有點不自然。無論是兒子直接地說出媽媽的不快樂與寂寞,或是媽媽對兒子的毫無辦法,聽起來不像角色的性格直接,而像是把潛台詞或人設喊了出來。
碎一地蘚苔
Beginners比較聚焦,但是我覺得反而表現了人的複雜,其實把非常多纖細又難以言明的事說得很好。《20世紀》給我的感覺則像是一群角色被又大又細的橡皮筋套在一起,都想向外突破些什麼可是一直回到原點,彼此間的交互作用我覺得挺好的!(最後大家也都離開了這個過段時間便失去彈性和約束性的橡皮圈)
碎一地蘚苔
Abbie和William上床前的那段我很喜歡,尤其最後的" I'm sorry.“ 無論William或Abbie的表達、表情都太好了...。
碎一地蘚苔
喜歡前段大家交錯唸彼此的生平,後面則是各自唸了後來的生活。表現的是彼此認識以及彼此疏離。
覺得這種分離感好真實啊。
碎一地蘚苔
一如往常,Mike Mills就是金句大師。
碎一地蘚苔
“You get to see him out in the world… as a person. I never will.”
這句真是戳到親子關係的痛處。
碎一地蘚苔
" I thought that was just the beginning of a new relationship with her, where she’d really tell me stuff. But maybe it was never really like that again. Maybe that was it."
覺得好有共鳴,很多以為會持續下去的事,其實只有一次的機會而已。
碎一地蘚苔
“Yeah, it’s like they’ve got this feeling, and they don’t have any skill, and they don’t want skill, because it’s really interesting what happens when your passion is bigger than the tools you have to deal with it. It creates this energy that’s raw. Isn’t it great?”
碎一地蘚苔
“When you were born I told you life was very big and unknown. There were animals and cities and music. You’d fall in love, have passions, have meaning. But now it’s 1979 and nothing means anything and I know you less everyday.”
碎一地蘚苔
“Having your heart broken is a tremendous way to learn about the world.”
碎一地蘚苔
Dorothea, “Men always feel that they have to fix things for women, but they’re not doing anything. Some things just can’t be fixed. Just be there, somehow that’s hard for all of you.”
Jamie, " I’m not all men, I’m just me. "
Dorothea, " Well, yes and no. "
碎一地蘚苔
Julie, "But yeah, half the time I regret it.
Jamie, "So why do you do it??"
Julie, "Half the time I don’t regret it."
碎一地蘚苔
“I’ll try to explain to him what his grandmother was like, but it will be impossible.”
這句讓我想到Louder Than Bombs
ωσғғʏ🥂
我也是比較喜歡Beginners,導致後來很多人表示喜歡這部時我都會說務必看看前作 XDDD 。但無論如何Mike Mills式的碎碎念怎麼看都很迷人。
碎一地蘚苔
ωσғғʏ🥂 : 真的.....好期待他老調重彈(O
載入新的回覆