I'm going to vote no just because if we're trying to take the game into a direction that is more serious, world building, plot driven... something like this will actually be like taking a step backward.
Part of the reason I wanted to suggest it is because we've got so much big stuff coming up along with Maya's excursion and our plots following afterwards, we want some small things beforehand
my vote's no. Unless this affects something other than speech pattern, I really can't see how it will lead to anything cr-wise other than a few network posts of "yarr what be this black magic arr"
The name tag event was pretty awesome and that was also simple. Maybe adding a level to the pirate day thing could take it from just a random fun thing to something to help generate CR,
wouldn't it be more ironic if they WERE on the boats by thentalking like pirates on boats lmao