[starting a ] How attractive/unattractive are my characters?

Thor: let's be honest here

Pretty attractive

Elodin: He used to be a suave, sexy motherfucker. Then he went crazy

now he looks a little bit too unhinged, and "bathing is optional right?" to be entirely attractive

Kincaid: Kind of average, his one saving grace is that he's in good shape, and years of lean rations from being a pirate have left not an ounce of fat on him

Hayato: The best you can get out of Hayato is "Compellingly ugly."

I mean he started (here)

and then he got a bunch of scars on his face

at least he grew out of looking like frankenstein, but he will never be sexy unless you're into "crazy old man"

Kamina: Is probably pretty good looking, but again that showers-optional thing put a damper on it. He makes no effort at hygeine, but he'd clean up good

Ricasthix: By the standards of dragons, he's that weird tall pale gangly guy with glasses.

So, if you're into that?

He's a huge nerd basically

His human form actually looks better to humans than his dragon form does to dragons

Ionae: Looks kind of generally unhealthy at all times. Her rating of 6/10 for herself wasn't really that far off

If she started taking care of herself and went into tastefully applied make up and flattering clothes, she could maybe get herself up to "not bad", but she'll never be ostentatiously pretty.